“Calm Down Rosa Luxemburg!”

Wit and education only give a bad argument the gloss of authority. The quote of the title comes from a criticism of the women’s rights campaigner Maryam Namazie. In the middle of an exchange on Twitter, concerning women’s rights in the Islamic world, @CordobaRises was reduced to this lofty slumming. It serves as an interesting example of the two, lowest ranks of argument; ranks of argument in a hierarchy that no amount of erudition can obscure. If you address the premise of an argument directly you get promoted to the top of the scale; if you bypass the premise and aim for the person, you are arguing from the gutter.

There is an argument that engages you, infuriates you, troubles you. There is also the person or group making the argument. The two form a unit in your mind so that the ‘message’ and the ‘messenger’ are hard to distinguish. When facing an engaging, infuriating, troubling person our whole personality is enlisted and the argument becomes more an emotional battle than a battle of ideas. We feel the need to win this battle because our basic survival attitudes are activated; we are not debating we are fighting; we are not in our minds but in our bodies. We become the Blefuscu Big-Endians or the Lilliput Little-Endians of ‘Gulliver’s Travels’ who war and enslave because of an arcane, theological dispute over dietary law. There is an emotional escalation in which the argument descends the scale – from idea to person.

How do we address the idea and not the person? Here is a proposition: Leprechauns exist. Now immediately we know that the person making this statement is a sad, deluded fool who can’t tell the difference between fact and fiction. Actually we don’t know that, what we know is our emotional reaction to something that sounds so ridiculous – and we express it as a criticism of the person, not the proposition. A claim such as leprechauns existing has the burden of proof and requires evidence. If someone turns up with a video of a group of disgruntled leprechauns complaining about the constant shoemaking and the compulsory wearing of green, then we don’t have a deluded fool we have a scientist. But of course the chances of such a video are next to zero and we are justified in dismissing the claim from the beginning.

If we disagree that there are leprechauns, we can express our disagreement in one of five levels of argument:

1. Refutation. “There is no evidence for leprechauns”
2. Counterargument. “Your evidence is as scant as a leprechaun’s beard”
3. Argument Tone. “Even a leprechaun wouldn’t be that unreasonable”
4. Ad Hominem. “You only believe in leprechauns because you’re trying to sell me this red wig”
5. Name Calling. “Your mother’s a leprechaun”

You can see from the @CordobaRises comment “Calm down Rosa Luxemburg” that far from being sophisticated rhetoric it is actually at the bottom of the pile. It is ‘ad hominem’ in not addressing the argument but the person, and it is ‘name calling’ even if that name is Rosa Luxemburg. I actually tweeted this point to @CordobaRises who’s response was to tell me I had spelt ‘Luxembourg’ (sic) wrong – again ‘ad hominem’. Of course, the aim of this controlled, aggressive comment was to denigrate Maryam Namazie’s feminism and her communism and provoke a similar level of aggressive response.

You might think it fine to provoke low-level response and to name call – a House of Commons debate is full of MPs who obviously think so – but the actual result is a lowering of the debate to common denominators. It is not long before the argument is polarised and each side is hurling extreme criticisms at each other. Eventually all such arguments end in Godwin’s Law: “You are a Nazi”. At this point everyone should realise they have hit the basement and should stop descending – unless the other team really are Nazis!

111 thoughts on ““Calm Down Rosa Luxemburg!”

  1. dilts.g-u.su says:

    dilts.g-u.su

    dilts.g-u.su

  2. anatoliy-alekseyevich-derkach.ru

    anatoliy-alekseyevich-derkach.ru

  3. periactin pediatric dosage

    periactin pediatric dosage

  4. is tizanidine hydrochloride 4 mg a narcotic

    is tizanidine hydrochloride 4 mg a narcotic

  5. what are the side effects of taking azathioprine

    what are the side effects of taking azathioprine

  6. que significa piroxicam

    que significa piroxicam

  7. what is the pill mobic

    what is the pill mobic

  8. baclofen verkrijgbaarheid

    baclofen verkrijgbaarheid

  9. how long does it take for amitriptyline to work

    how long does it take for amitriptyline to work

  10. injectable imitrex instructions

    injectable imitrex instructions

  11. elavil dosage range

    elavil dosage range

  12. mebeverine hydrochloride ulotka

    mebeverine hydrochloride ulotka

  13. where can i buy cheap pyridostigmine without insurance

    where can i buy cheap pyridostigmine without insurance

  14. carbamazepine amitriptyline interaction

    carbamazepine amitriptyline interaction

  15. sulfasalazine and depression

    sulfasalazine and depression

  16. gabapentin priapism

    gabapentin priapism

  17. tegretol and alcohol effects

    tegretol and alcohol effects

  18. tadalafil 60 mg vidalista

    tadalafil 60 mg vidalista

  19. online pharmacy ativan

    online pharmacy ativan

  20. can you buy misoprostol pharmacy

    can you buy misoprostol pharmacy

  21. vardenafil 20mg india

    vardenafil 20mg india

  22. sildenafil dose for high blood pressure

    sildenafil dose for high blood pressure

  23. vardenafil aurochem 20mg

    vardenafil aurochem 20mg

  24. generic pharmacy online

    generic pharmacy online

  25. real viagra online pharmacy

    real viagra online pharmacy

  26. best time to take cialis

    best time to take cialis

  27. levitra buy generic

    levitra buy generic

  28. levitra 10mg says:

    levitra 10mg

    levitra 10mg

  29. Verapamil says:

    Verapamil

    Verapamil

  30. how long does it take tadalafil to work

    how long does it take tadalafil to work

  31. tadalafil effects

    tadalafil effects

  32. how long does levitra stay in your system

    how long does levitra stay in your system

  33. sildenafil 100mg price

    sildenafil 100mg price

  34. sildenafil tablet

    sildenafil tablet

  35. mexico pharmacy valium

    mexico pharmacy valium

  36. cheapest generic levitra online

    cheapest generic levitra online

  37. tadalafil dosage daily

    tadalafil dosage daily

  38. cristiano ronaldo skills

    cristiano ronaldo skills hi i am a football skiller

  39. football skills

    football skills hello i am a football player

  40. internet Sitesi Kurma

    Kurumsal internet sitesi kurma paketlerini inceledim, en uygununu secip 1 haftada teslim aldigim.

  41. buy instagram followers

    The followers I bought seemed authentic at first, but engagement is still low.

  42. Konya SEO Uzmanı

    Konya SEO uzmanı, Selçuklu motiflerini meta etiketlere dönüştürüyor.

  43. track phone location

    The location tracker accuracy is spot-on. Perfect for coordinating meetups with friends.

  44. lisinopril kidney damage reversible

    lisinopril kidney damage reversible

  45. pregabalin 100 mg capsule

    pregabalin 100 mg capsule

  46. cipro alcohol

    cipro alcohol

  47. doxycycline hyc

    doxycycline hyc

  48. cephalexin for strep

    cephalexin for strep

  49. keflex and birth control

    keflex and birth control

  50. trazodone and melatonin

    trazodone and melatonin

  51. ampicillin normal dosage

    ampicillin normal dosage

  52. augmentin antibiotic

    augmentin antibiotic

  53. ivermectin ireland

    ivermectin ireland

  54. ivermectin pills human

    ivermectin pills human

  55. cost of ivermectin 3mg tablets

    cost of ivermectin 3mg tablets

  56. ivermectin 6 mg tablets

    ivermectin 6 mg tablets

  57. stromectol tablets buy online

    stromectol tablets buy online

  58. levitra vardenafil 20 mg

    levitra vardenafil 20 mg

  59. rx care pharmacy orlando fl

    rx care pharmacy orlando fl

  60. buy viagra cialis levitra online

    buy viagra cialis levitra online

  61. sildenafil side effects in females

    sildenafil side effects in females

  62. venlafaxine long term side effects

    venlafaxine long term side effects

  63. dapagliflozin sitagliptin and metformin hydrochloride uses in hindi

    dapagliflozin sitagliptin and metformin hydrochloride uses in hindi

  64. actos fanaticos

    actos fanaticos

  65. what is protonix 40 mg

    what is protonix 40 mg

  66. ivermectin 0.5% lotion

    ivermectin 0.5% lotion

  67. semaglutide lozenges

    semaglutide lozenges

  68. abilify and alcohol

    abilify and alcohol

  69. acarbose fda says:

    acarbose fda

    acarbose fda

  70. ashwagandha testosterone

    ashwagandha testosterone

  71. augmentin and alcohol webmd

    augmentin and alcohol webmd

  72. buspar generic

    buspar generic

  73. what is celebrex for

    what is celebrex for

  74. celecoxib generic name

    celecoxib generic name

  75. allopurinol during gout attack

    allopurinol during gout attack

  76. amitriptyline dosage for sleep reviews

    amitriptyline dosage for sleep reviews

  77. how long does it take effexor to work

    how long does it take effexor to work

  78. 1 month contrave results pictures forum

    1 month contrave results pictures forum

  79. farmaco per colesterolo ezetimibe

    farmaco per colesterolo ezetimibe

  80. diltiazem side effects elderly

    diltiazem side effects elderly

  81. depakote drug interaction

    depakote drug interaction

  82. does flexeril cause constipation

    does flexeril cause constipation

  83. augmentin yeast infection

    augmentin yeast infection

  84. best time of day to take citalopram

    best time of day to take citalopram

  85. conditions treated by amoxicillin

    conditions treated by amoxicillin

  86. vxi.su says:

    vxi.su

    vxi.su

  87. bactrim suspension dose

    bactrim suspension dose

  88. what are the side effects of bactrim

    what are the side effects of bactrim

  89. cephalexin during pregnancy

    cephalexin during pregnancy

  90. Spiral Dynamics

    Spiral Dynamics

  91. spiraldynamics

    spiraldynamics

  92. sildenafil 150mg tablets

    sildenafil 150mg tablets

  93. is cymbalta a stimulant

    is cymbalta a stimulant

  94. do zoloft side effects go away

    do zoloft side effects go away

  95. rybelsus 7 mg tablet 10

    rybelsus 7 mg tablet 10

  96. glucophage glimepiride

    glucophage glimepiride

  97. nolvadex prolactin

    nolvadex prolactin

  98. does lyrica show up on a drug screen

    does lyrica show up on a drug screen

  99. molluscum valtrex

    molluscum valtrex

  100. metronidazole engourdissement

    metronidazole engourdissement

  101. sulfamethoxazole oral

    sulfamethoxazole oral

  102. cialis brand no prescription needed

    cialis brand no prescription needed

  103. cheap generic viagra canadian pharmacy

    cheap generic viagra canadian pharmacy

  104. real viagra online canadian pharmacy

    real viagra online canadian pharmacy

  105. female viagra sale in singapore

    female viagra sale in singapore

  106. vipps certified pharmacy viagra

    vipps certified pharmacy viagra

  107. purchase generic viagra

    purchase generic viagra

  108. amoxicillin target pharmacy

    amoxicillin target pharmacy

  109. how long does it take for cialis to work

    how long does it take for cialis to work

  110. tadalafil says:

    tadalafil

    tadalafil

Comments are closed.